Janaagraha
Janaagraha
Meter down on India’s Museums
Meter down on India’s Museums - By Ramesh Ramanathan
It’s vacation time for our two children, ages sixteen and eleven. As summer rolls around each year, my wife and I worry about how they can be meaningfully occupied. We are working parents, with fairly active travel schedules. While we love the idea of lazy summer days – given our own pleasant memories of boisterous sessions with numerous cousins – the nuclear family has eliminated these options. I guess we have also become more concerned parents – too concerned perhaps? - worrying about the quality of our children’s leisure time.
When we lived overseas, the museum would always be a time-sucking sponge. Countless weekend and holiday hours were spent in museums of various kinds - natural history, art, science. We also found them to be extraordinary public spaces, filled with people of all colours, classes and ages: grandparents taking their young wards for an afternoon trip; tourists wanting to know more about a country and its culture; schoolteachers waving a group of eight-graders along; a wheelchair-occupant oblivious to his disability.
Museums are more than edutainment for casual visitors. A report titled, “Understanding the future – Museums and 21st century life” by the British government says, “Museums are the way we connect our past with our present and our future. Museums are centres of knowledge, with a clear and growing role as educators. They support the creative industries. They act as a powerful engine for regeneration, their impact on the economy, and the tangible effect they have on the imagination and spirit of the people who visit them, is enormous.” Ultimately, museums are “a means of helping citizens understand their place in the world.”
A few weeks ago, running out of holiday options, we took our children along on an overseas working trip, promising them sightseeing and time with friends. Despite the hectic schedule, the tug of the museum couldn’t be resisted, and we squeezed out half-a-day for the London Science Museum.
At first, the thought of spending a beautiful spring day stuck indoors didn’t appeal to the children. But their eyes widened as they walked into the hallway and saw an escalator riding up through what seemed like the centre of the earth. By the end of the evening, they were filled with the energy of discovery, laughing as they twirled the large disk that demonstrated coriolis force, and awestruck at the raw power of a volcano. Our son, whose only interest in dinosaurs until then had been restricted to filmy blood-and-gore, got an unforgettable lesson on the intricacies of an archaeological dig.
I can’t help feeling distressed as I compare these remarkable centres to our own museums in India. And sorry for the thousands of schoolchildren who are wasting their summer days, when they could be filling their heads with the liberating air of ideas. Approximately ten million 17-year olds in the country took their 12th grade examinations this year. Of those from Karnataka, only 50% passed. This means that two-and-a-half lakh teenagers in the state – 50 lakhs nationwide, if the statistics can be extrapolated - are in an academic dead-end, likely to become part of our collective social problem a decade later. And another fifty lakhs next year. And the next.
Our country has many obvious and overwhelming challenges. Set against these, the idea of building vibrant museums sounds trivial and perhaps somewhat indulgent. But it’s strange how even the smallest of interventions can have an unexpected multiplier effect. While the education problem is vast and complex, and many remarkable minds are hard at the task, I can’t help feeling that museums could help. By providing that one inspiring moment, one glimpse of a world of different possibilities to motivate a child to dream beyond their immediate surroundings.
I have spoken to a few museum directors in our country, hoping to find sparks of enthusiasm. Unfortunately, most of them have either flamed out like fireflies or are isolated and too deeply buried beneath our ossified attitudes towards museums. Transforming our museums will first require a transformation in our mindset towards museums. We need to go beyond treating museums as mausoleums of mothballed memories, and bring them alive with creative and innovative programming, connected to our cities’ economies and supported at least partially by private funding.
The amazing thing about a country with a billion people is that there are always champions of change, passionately pursuing their cause. Hope is a tantalising emotion. I can’t wait for the day when I can spend an enthralling Sunday afternoon with my children, lost in the corridors of a delightful Indian museum.
_______________________________________________________________________
The author is Co-Founder of Janaagraha.
Re: Meter down on India’s Museums
Dear Ramesh and Swati,
Probably you may have visited the Community Science Centre at ahmedabad when you were students as this place is one of the best science activity centres of its kind anywhere. I literally grew up there from 1968 onwards! The centre (now called VASCSC - ikram A Sarabhai Community Science Centre)was started in 1963 almost the same time as The Exploratorium (founded by Oppenheimer in 1966)at San Francisco which i consider the mother of all such science musuems.
The govt. of India under the aegis of the National Science Museums opened over 54 similar copy cats museums all over the country -but look at the conditions of all of them including the science museum in bangalore. children hardly learn much from these centres today and is more of a picnic and day out of school. (The new science centre in Ahmedabad whose budget runs into crores is another example of great ideas, but no detailing and pathetic execution. )
The Calcutta sceince centre is supposed to be better but i have not seen it as yet. Delhi, Mumbai, Goa, Jaipur - lots of great oppourtunities but typical of all such government drives - they fail in their main function.
And one who has spent a lot of time as a student, as a faculty and as a coordinator of such activities - it needs people with passion and drive. the money is not the critical element.
There are a band of us who are keenly interested in working on such activities and if we can work out a platform we should do ths. Currently am trying to spread the concept of outdoor science parks through a corporate body. The outddor science park was also the brain child of Dr Vikram Sarabhai and the director of the New york Science Centre admits on his website , that he got this phenomenal idea from here Ahmedabad) and spread aroud the world!!!! SO we do have a lot to offer, but unfortunately we get turned on by petty issues like power and money and forget we have the responsibility to educate our future generations in exciting ways if we truly want a better future. I ahve much more to add, suggest etc. but probably not here.
regards,
Amit Sheth.
Re: Meter down on India’s Museums
Your articles are almost always thought-provoking. It is amazing how just a few committed people can make such a difference in bringing about beneficial change in thoughts, words and deeds of the citizens at large.
We wish you continued success in your missionary efforts!
Re: Meter down on India’s Museums
On an appreciative note, thanks a lot for bringing the "Museum" dimension to the forefront of discussion. Do certainly feel that the little than has been done by museums like Vishveshwaraya and the entities like the Planetarium can truly inspire our younger generation.
On the aspect of 'Metering" pardon me for digressing, but feel very strongly that as we watch a precious resource being consumed and not being adequately monitored, we should raise this too. What I'm referring to is :WATER. Why do our housing colonies with hundreds of flats & consuming millions of litres of water, nit want to 'meter' this at each flat? Why are folk content with the status quo, where someone who hoses down his car and bathes in a bathtub may pay the same for water consumed as another who bathes in a 2 minutes under a shower or uses a mug or two to wipe his vehicle? As you so well stated: But it’s strange how even the smallest of interventions can have an unexpected multiplier effect.
Re: Meter down on India’s Museums
Dear Mr Ramnathan,
Our family helped build in 2004 a Science Museum by contributing 34 lacs to a school Bal Vidhyalaya, established 50 years back by Bal Hitkari Samiti in Kota (Rajasthan). Located within the school premises is the first of its kind in the state of Rajasthan or perhaps in India. The museum is named as Paras Mool Chand Chatter Science Museum.
Though the museum is maintained well but it is not being given proper publicity not even amongst the schools in and around Kota and neigbouring cities.
This is perhaps due to unawareness in the management committee of the school, of the Power of this medium to connect the thoughts of a child or for that matter any person visiting it, to the Evolution and Development of Science and its basics.
I believe unless and untill our people, the younger ones or the grownups start asking "Why" we can not produce the Confident Population.
The Science / Mechanism of Art to Live as a Confident Countryman automatically develops if we inculcate the habit of asking "Why" to our satisfaction.
Your email has made me strong in my perception that Making people to vist Science Museum will definitely help build a Confident Society. I'll be forwarding a hard copy of your mail to the school management also.
Regards
Ampi Chatter
Re: Meter down on India’s Museums
Very thought provoking article. I remember my trips to Viswewaraiah museum several years back - some good stuff and then some other exhibits broken and out of order (india's famous signboard)!!
And then my mind compares this with the museums that I saw in NY & Washington much later which literally overawe you with huge hallways, architectural splendor and clever tricks to attract people of all ages to provide them a unique experience. Alas when will they come to India!!
I also amazed by the author's command over English and the narrative not just in this but all other Janaagraha articles I have read so far!
Regards
Karthik